Survey on Mental Health of Iranian Medical Students: A Cross- sectional Study in Islamic Azad University
Shiraz E-Medical Journal: July 2017, 18 (7); e14929
June 25, 2017
Article Type: Research Article
April 3, 2017
June 10, 2017
June 24, 2017
S A, Mirzaei
A. Survey on Mental Health of Iranian Medical Students: A Cross- sectional Study in Islamic Azad University,
Shiraz E-Med J.
Copyright © 2017, Shiraz E-Medical Journal. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits copy and redistribute the material just in noncommercial usages, provided the original work is properly cited.
Mental health requires awareness of human basic requirements (
1). Medical university students are special persons in a society, because they are usually more intelligent than their nonmedical peers; they can achieve better social and economic status, and benefit more from the funds of their country and frequent studies ( 2- 4). Sometimes, the border between mental health and neurosis (mental disorders) interlace together, and thus unhealthy individuals are not detected properly ( 1- 3). Therefore, many professionals and scientific centers try to suggest clear and precise definition of mental health ( 5).
University entrance is a highly sensitive stage during youths’ life in every country, and it frequently accompanies with several changes in their social relationships (
4). During this time, some stresses and anxieties are inflicted to the junior university students and affect their performance and efficiency ( 6). Many stressors threaten mental health of medical students such as educational debt, heavy studies and workload, information and data overload, sleep difficulty, medical school environments, poor learning devices, and financial and economic concerns ( 7- 10).
The general health questionnaire (GHQ) was regulated by Goldberg in 1972 for the first time, and was applied widely to diagnose minor mental disorders in different situations (
11). The prevalence of mental health disorders in the past studies were determined using the GHQ, ranging from 7.3% to 40.2% worldwide. A study conducted in Turkey showed that 47.9% of medical students had emotional disorders; and in a Malaysian study, it was found that 41.9% of medical students experienced emotional disorders ( 8, 9).
However, there is limited information in the literature on the survey of mental health of Iranian medical students at Islamic Azad University. Thus, this study, for the first time, was done at the Islamic Azad University with the aim of evaluating mental health among medical students of Islamic Azad University in Tehran during 2014.
2.1. Design, Participants, and Procedures
The present cross-sectional study was done to evaluate mental health among all students (907 students in different fields of study such as biology, health, medical, paramedical, medical engineering, nursing, and midwifery) of Islamic Azad University of Medical Sciences in Tehran, the capital of Iran during 2014. The census sampling method was applied and 907 participants were included in the study.
This study was approved by the research ethics committee of Islamic Azad University of Medical Sciences in Tehran and participants provided written voluntary informed consent. The present study was performed by a clinical psychologist and a senior psychiatry resident.
2.2. Measurement Method
The questionnaire consisted of 2 parts: (1) demographic information, (2) mental health tests. For this study, the general health questionnaire (GHQ) was distributed by project supervision among new students in September 2014, when they were enrolling. The questionnaire included 28 questions (with 4 subscales) about general symptoms of mental disorders. Every subscale included symptoms of physical, anxiety, depression, and social function. Likert scale was used to score the GHQ. Each question has 4 choices, which are scored between 0 and 3 (not at all, usual, mostly, almost always), and a score between 0 and 84 can be obtained. According to the Cronbach’s alpha coefficient test, the cut of point of 23 was determined in the present study. GHQ test results were 90% and 88% for females and males, respectively, which is statistically acceptable.
2.3. Statistical Analysis
The questionnaires were completed by the students without any compulsion. All the obtained data were analyzed by SPSS version 19 (SPSS Inc. Chicago, IL, USA) and its results were reported by analytical methods such as Fisher test, Chi- square test, and correlation coefficient.
In total, 907 students enrolled in this study (
Table 1). Participants were females with a mean age of 21.3 ± 2.9 years and males with a mean age of 20.9 ± 2.7 years. Demographic characteristics of the participants are presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of the Students
Variables No. (%) Gender Male 170 (19) Female 737 (81) Total 893 (100) Marital Status Single 869 (95.8) Married 38 (4.2) Total 907 (100) Family history of mental diseases Yes 35 (3.9) No 859 (96.1) Total 907 (100) Educational level Bachelor 716 (78.9) Master 63 (7) Doctorate 128 (14.1) Total 907 (100) Field of study Biology 204 (22.6) Health 62 (6.7) Nursing 91 (10) Midwifery 28 (3.1) Medical engineering 135 (14.9) Medicine 128 (14.1) Paramedical 133 (14.7) Psychology 126 (13.9)
According to the results, 81% of students had mental health and only 19% had mental problems. Frequency of GHQ subtests according to gender and marital status are demonstrated in
Table 2. Frequency of GHQ Subtests According to Gender and Marital Status
Physical Anxiety Social Function Depression Male 168 (19) 168 (19) 168 (19) 168 Female 720 (81) 720 (81) 718 (81) 718 Total 888 888 886 886 Single 832 (96) 832 (96) 830 (96) 830 (96) Married 30 (4) 30 (4) 30 (4) 30 (4) Total 862 862 860 860
The results revealed a significant difference in physical (P = 0.000), anxiety (P = 0.004), and total scores (P = 0.019) between female and male groups, but no significant difference was found in their social (P = 0.996) and depression (P = 0.503) scores. No significant difference was detected between single and married groups (
Table 3). The results indicated no significant difference among physical, anxiety, social function, depression, and total scores in GHQ subtests (P = N.S).
Table 3. Comparison of the Gender of GHQ Subtests
Depression Social Function Anxiety Physical Total Male Healthy 92.3 53.6 83.9 91.1 82.1 No healthy 7.7 46.4 16.1 8.9 17.9 Female Healthy 92.8 52.6 76.5 84.9 80.5 No healthy 7.2 47.7 23.5 15.1 19.5 T = -0.669, df = 884, P = 0.503 T = 0.005, df = 884, P = 0.996 T = -2.891, df = 886, P = 0.004 T = -4.080, df = 886, P = 0.000 T = -2.354, df = 884, P = 0.019
aValues are expressed as %.
The mental health of university students in different fields were compared together. According to the results of ANOVA test, a significant difference was obtained in subtests (
Table 4. Comparison of Mental Health Status of Students with Field of Study with ANOVA Test
Subtest Mean ± SD F P Value Anxiety 4.3 ± 3.4 1.897 0.027 Social Function 6.2 ± 2.7 1.897 0.040 Depression 1.9 ± 2.8 2.227 0.007 Total Score 16.3 ± 9.2 1.972 0.020
The comparison of students with/without family history of mental disease has been demonstrated in
Table 5. The results revealed a significant difference between the 2 groups.
Table 5. The Comparison of Students with/without Family History of Mental Disease
GHQ Free Degree F P Value Physical Intergroup 1 17.673 0.000 Intragroup 892 Total 893 Anxiety Intergroup 1 28.318 0.000 Intragroup 892 Total 893 Depression Intergroup 1 2.067 0.151 Intragroup 892 Total 893 Social function Intergroup 1 35.329 0.000 Intragroup 892 Total 893 Total score Intergroup 1 30.950 0.000 Intragroup 892 Total 893
According to the results, a group with family history of mental disease has faced more physical problems, anxiety, and depression, but there was no significant difference in social function among them.
The results revealed that 19.5% of students were suspected of having a mental disorder. Various studies have provided different results. Health and social care information centre (2009) reported that about 23% of adult students had at least one psychiatry condition (
1). In another study conducted in Oroumiyeh university (2010), it was reported that 6.2% of students were suspected of having a mental disorder ( 12). Bahreynian and Ghasemi Borumand studies showed 28.6% of female students and 25% of male students were suspected to have mental disorder ( 13). However, Tabrizizadeh et al. reported that 30.9% of medical and dentistry students at Yazd University were suspected of having mental disorders ( 14).
A survey on mental health of the medical students at London University and Cardiff Medical schools presented in international conference on physician health in London (2014), showed that 17% of the students completed the survey, 15% had depression, and 52% had anxiety disorder (
According to the study, 19.5% of female students suffered from mental disorder (15.1% physical disorder, 23.5% anxiety, 47.4% depression, and 7.2% social function). These findings match those of Karami and Tabrizizadeh studies. The rate of male students who had mental disorder was 17.9% and there was no significant difference between male and female students (P = NS). Of the male students, 8.2% suffered from physical disorder, 16.1% anxiety, 46.4% depression, and 7.7% from social function. Based on the obtained results, the most common disorders between male and female students were depression and anxiety, which was in agreement with those of Karami study in Zanjan University of Medical Sciences (
No significant difference was found between the students who had a family history of mental disorder and those without it. The existence of mental illness in the students’ family can affect them in 2 ways: firstly, through gene transfer and inheritance; secondly through unfavorable family environment for normal communication. These problems can appear as a stress on students’ life. There was no significant difference between female and male students with family history of mental illness in the subtest of GHQ and the total score. There was no significant difference among students, education degree, and mental health. These results matched those of Sadeghi at Qom University of Medical Sciences (
12). 4.1. Limitations
It might have been possible that some students did not answer the questions due to anxiety and lack of knowledge. Besides, these findings showed only the suspected students with mental disorders, and thus they cannot represent the population of real mental patients.
The results of this study revealed that mental disorders were common among students of Islamic Azad University of Medical Sciences (students studying in the fields of biology, health, medical, paramedical, medical engineering, nursing and midwifery) and that mental disorders were more common among female students. Our results demonstrated that 19.5% of medical students were suspected to have a mental disorder. Academic stress could have a major effect on the mental health of medical students.